PHIL 120 Orange Coast College Euthanasia and Life Support Discussion

Description

Topic: Euthanasia —— Scenario: Life Support

Molly was nearing the point at which she no longer believed her life was worth living. She had a rare disease that slowly eroded her mental functioning without affecting the health of her body. Within a year, she would be a mental vegetable. She wanted to end things now.

Dr. Grey was sympathetic, but he would not comply with Molly’s wishes for a lethal injection. “That would be murder,” he explained to Molly, “and I am a doctor, not a murder.”

“So when I go brain-dead, I’ll just be put on life-support for decades, draining away all of my family’s financial resources?” Molly asked.

That won’t be necessary,” Dr. Grey responded. “When you go brain-dead, we can stop feeding you.”

“What’s the difference?” Molly asked. “Either way you’re responsible for my death. And if you give me the lethal injection now, you save me a great deal of needless suffering.”

“The difference is between killing you and letting you die,” Dr. Grey replied. “And, as I said, I’m not a murderer.”

Questions to consider for your answer:

  • Molly is asking for euthanasia, also known as “mercy killing.” Set aside questions of legality. Would Dr. Grey be doing something morally wrong if he gave Molly a lethal injection? What would be an argument for both sides?
  • Is there really a difference between killing and letting die? Can you think of cases in which there is a clear moral difference between the two? Can you think of cases in which there is not a clear moral difference?

Then, analyze these questions: Is Molly wrong to ask for an early death? Is Dr. Grey acting immorally by rejecting her request? Make sure to make a firm claim about what you think is morally correct and offer an argument for why this is the case.


Solution:

We have the solution to this question. However, to avoid posible plagiarism, let us provide a fully custom and original solution. Please talk to any of our homework helpers via the chat icons at the bottom of your screen.

Psst!!! Let us do your homework for you!

Do you need expert help with your homework? Are you busy and would like an extra hand with your essays, homework and assignments? Try us today for the best grades in class!

Send us a message!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top