University of California Irvine Trolley and Time Travel Problem Essay

Description

Write an essay of about 4 pages (or 1000 words). Your Essay 2 is due at 11am on Thursday, February 25 , 2021.

Writing in your own words, address the following instructions.

In this essay you consider two very different types of “paradoxical” situations. The Trolley problem poses a moral dilemma: what should one do when moral intuitions seem to conflict? The Time Traveler problem poses a metaphysical quandary: how shall we understand whether time travel is really possible when intuitions about space-time seem to conflict? In both cases we reason by thought experiment.

Part A. Choose one of three scenarios we have studied: (1) the trolley Driver, (2) the trolley Bystander, both from Judith Jarvis Thomson’s “The Trolley Problem” (1985), or alternatively (3) the Tesla Driver, from our variation in Lecture, where a human Tesla Driver is in charge. Does this scenario pose a moral “paradox” where two principles are in moral or practical contradiction? If you find two conflicting moral principles, briefly explain each, and how they conflict.

Part B. Consider a scenario drawing on David Lewis’ “The Paradoxes of Time Travel” (1976). Suppose a traveler leaves a place in 2021 and arrives by time travel at a place in 2016, where she meets herself and has a conversation with her prior self about whether to go to UCI or UCLA in 2018. Consider Lewis’ metaphysical principle that this traveler S is really a “streak” through time: a person S enduring through time and composed of temporal parts S-at-2021 and S-at-2016. Now, as we live our lives it seems rather that “I” (S in the first person) am meeting a different person “I” at an earlier time in “my” life. Does this self-conversation scenario pose a metaphysical “paradox” where these two considerations are in contradiction about reality? Is time travel possible?

Part C. Very briefly: Should we think of the Trolley puzzle and the Time-Travel puzzle as varieties of “paradox”? If so, what kind of contradiction is involved in each?

SOURCES: Use ONLY the assigned texts, Professor’s Notes, and your TA guidance.

The aim is to think about these styles of paradoxes. There is a huge amount of literature on all these themes, but you may get confused or even misled by reading around, and the aim here is NOT a “report” but an exercise in your own thinking carefully about the issues raised in our Lectures and Discussion sections in relation to just these sources.

Solution:

We have the solution to this question. However, to avoid posible plagiarism, let us provide a fully custom and original solution. Please talk to any of our homework helpers via the chat icons at the bottom of your screen.

Psst!!! Let us do your homework for you!

Do you need expert help with your homework? Are you busy and would like an extra hand with your essays, homework and assignments? Try us today for the best grades in class!

Send us a message!

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Scroll to Top